Select Page

Gap insurance is a crucial form of protection for vehicle owners, especially those who have leased or financed their vehicles. It covers the difference between the actual cash value of the vehicle and the amount owed on the vehicle, which can be thousands of dollars. While most major car insurance companies offer gap insurance, it can be challenging to determine which company is the best fit for your needs.

In this article, we’ll take a closer look at the top companies offering gap insurance, highlighting the unique features and benefits of each provider.

  1. Travelers Insurance

Travelers Insurance is an excellent option for those looking for affordable gap insurance coverage. The company’s premiums are typically lower than its competitors, making it an affordable choice for budget-conscious drivers. Travelers Insurance also has fewer customer complaints than the average car insurance company, indicating a higher level of customer satisfaction.

Travelers Insurance offers loan/lease gap coverage for approximately 5% of the car’s comprehensive and collision premium. However, only vehicles purchased directly from a new car dealer are eligible.

  1. The Hartford

The Hartford is an excellent choice for AARP members, as the company offers discounted rates and coverage tailored to senior citizens. The Hartford’s gap insurance must be added to your policy within the first 30 days after purchasing or leasing the vehicle.

  1. Liberty Mutual

Liberty Mutual offers gap insurance coverage that costs an average of $5-$15 per month, which may be more expensive than some competitors. However, if you already have your auto policy with the company, Liberty Mutual may be a good choice. Since gap insurance is typically only a small portion of your premium, it may be more cost-effective to focus on the price of your entire policy.

  1. Progressive

As the third-largest car insurance company in the United States, Progressive offers gap insurance coverage that can be easily added to your collision and comprehensive coverage. However, it may be advertised as “loan/lease payoff insurance.” The gap insurance of Progressive is limited to 125% of your vehicle’s actual cash value and, depending on your claim, may or may not cover your deductible. Progressive’s gap insurance minimizes the difference between the actual cash value of your car and the amount owing on that vehicle.

  1. Allstate

Allstate’s gap insurance, also known as guaranteed asset protection insurance, is available in most states and covers vehicles worth up to $100,000. Covered losses are limited to $50,000, which is a higher amount than many competitors. The gap insurance of Allstate covers deductibles up to $1,000 and can reduce your out-of-pocket expenses in the event of a total loss. You can purchase Allstate’s guaranteed asset protection insurance from dealers nationwide.

  1. American Family

American Family offers gap insurance coverage to customers in 19 states. To qualify for American Family gap insurance, you must first have an auto insurance policy with the company that includes collision and comprehensive coverage. The gap insurance of American Family can be purchased through independent agents.

  1. Amica

Amica is one of the few major providers in the United States to offer gap insurance coverage. The company has a strong reputation for customer service, claims satisfaction, and financial stability. Amica’s gap insurance covers the difference between the value of your vehicle and the amount you owe on that vehicle, similar to other gap insurance policies listed here.

  1. Nationwide

Nationwide is another major insurance provider that offers gap insurance coverage. It is an optional add-on available on certain vehicles and can cover deductibles, theft, total loss, and negative equity. Nationwide’s gap insurance adds an extra layer of protection to your car insurance policy.

Gap insurance is a critical form of protection for vehicle owners, especially those who have leased or financed their vehicles. While most major car insurance companies offer gap insurance,

Securing Your Investment: Choosing the Right Gap Insurance Provider in 2023

In the world of auto financing and leasing, gap insurance emerges as a vital safeguard, protecting you from the financial pitfalls that can occur when your vehicle’s value depreciates faster than your loan balance decreases. This additional article serves as a comprehensive guide to navigating the complexities of choosing the right gap insurance provider in 2023, enhancing your ability to make an informed decision based on your specific needs.

What is Gap Insurance?

Purpose and Importance

  • Financial Protection: Gap insurance covers the ‘gap’ between the amount you owe on your vehicle and its actual cash value (ACV) in the event of a total loss.
  • Essential for Leasers and Buyers with Low Down Payments: Particularly important if you lease your vehicle or purchase it with a small down payment, making it more likely that you owe more than the ACV of the car at any point.

2023’s Top Gap Insurance Providers: An Overview

Building on the earlier discussion of major providers, here are additional details and insights to consider when choosing a provider that aligns with your financial strategy and vehicle protection needs.

Features to Consider When Selecting a Provider

  • Coverage Limitations and Inclusions: Check what’s specifically covered by the gap insurance—some policies might offer coverage for related expenses such as extended warranties or insurance deductibles.
  • Cost vs. Coverage: While cost is a crucial factor, it’s also important to balance this with the comprehensiveness of the coverage.
  • Reputation and Reliability: Consider insurers recognized for customer satisfaction and ease of claims processing.

Detailed Review of Gap Insurance Providers

Here’s a closer look at some additional insurers known for their robust gap insurance offerings:


  • Coverage Details: Geico does not directly sell gap insurance but offers loan/lease payoff which covers up to 25% over the ACV of your car, providing significant protection against loan deficits.
  • Customer Service: Known for a high level of customer service and an efficient claims process.

State Farm

  • Coverage Integration: Offers Payoff Protector® with every vehicle loan, which is not exactly gap insurance but serves a similar purpose by covering the difference between the insurance payout and the remaining loan balance if your car is totaled.
  • Availability: Available to those who finance their vehicle purchase through State Farm Bank.

Evaluating Your Needs and Choosing the Right Provider

Steps to Choose the Right Gap Insurance

  • Assess Your Vehicle’s Depreciation: Faster-depreciating vehicles might benefit more from gap insurance.
  • Analyze Loan Terms: Longer loan terms often mean slower balance reduction, increasing the relevance of gap insurance.
  • Compare Quotes and Terms: Don’t just look at premiums—consider the extent of coverage and the provider’s service reputation.

Questions to Ask Potential Providers

  • What is the maximum coverage limit?
  • Are there any major exclusions I should be aware of?
  • Can the policy be cancelled at any time if I pay off my loan early, and is there a refund?
  • How is the claim process handled?

Making the Decision: Monthly vs. One-time Payment Options

Monthly Payments

  • Pros: Lower initial costs, easier integration with existing monthly budgets.
  • Cons: Possible additional administrative fees, generally higher total cost over the term.

Annual Payments

  • Pros: Often cheaper in the long run due to discounts for upfront payment.
  • Cons: Requires a larger amount of money upfront, which might not be feasible for everyone.

Ensuring Adequate Protection

As you consider gap insurance in 2023, remember that the best provider for you will depend on your specific circumstances—like your vehicle type, financing arrangement, and personal financial situation. By carefully evaluating each provider’s offerings against your needs, you can secure the right coverage to protect yourself from unexpected financial burdens in the event of a total loss. Remember, in the event of a claim, gap insurance can significantly mitigate the financial impact, aligning your debt with the depreciated value of your vehicle and ensuring financial stability.